Trust. It’s the only thing that matters.
Great insurance starts with a great relationship.
Rooted in Indiana, we serve individuals, families, farmers and businesses across twelve states.
At Chittick Insurance, we bring local knowledge and a personal touch to every client we serve. As an independent agency, we work with a broad network of top-rated carriers so we can shop the market on your behalf and tailor coverage to fit your needs and budget.
Whether you’re a homeowner protecting what matters most, a farmer safeguarding your operation, or a business owner managing complex risks, from contractors and restaurants to retailers and beyond, we have the expertise to build the right program for you.
Our team is committed to more than policies. We’re committed to understanding your exposures, protecting your assets and being there when you need us most. At Chittick Insurance, you’re not just a client. You’re part of our community.
Small-town values
Honest advice. If there’s a coverage you need, we’ll tell you. The choice is always yours.
Independent by design
We represent you, not one insurance company, and compare carriers to find the right fit.
There when it counts
Claims, changes and questions are handled by people who already know your account.
Rest assured in our services.
Buying a home can be a nerve-wracking experience. Whether it’s your first home, a downsize, or a quiet place in the woods for retirement, our access to a variety of carriers gives you real choices and coverage in place on time.
- Fast proof of insurance for your lender
- Home, auto and umbrella coordinated together
- Exceptional service, more than you expect
A historic storefront, built for real conversations.
Original brick, big front windows and desks made for sitting down together. Stop in, or we’ll come to you.
Answered on a Saturday. Covered before we went home.
“When I was in an accident on a Saturday and needed to know how to use the roadside assistance and towing on my policy, they answered and stayed on the phone with me until everything was handled. A short time later, I purchased a new car and the staff stayed after-hours to be sure I was adequately covered before going home.”
“As a small business owner with ever changing needs, Chittick Insurance is beyond incredible. Matt responds within 1 working day, is helpful navigating the insurance world in terms I understand, and truly has my best interest in mind as an entrepreneur.”
“They made the process of purchasing home insurance so seamless and easy. I couldn’t have gotten through my home buying process without them.”
“He listened carefully in order to understand my small business’s insurance needs and then crafted solutions that fit the need perfectly, and at a very reasonable price.”
“My family has been with Chittick Insurance for years and they have always taken great care of us. They make sure we know our options so we can make the smartest choices.”
“Matt was able to greatly increase my business coverage at a much better price. Their response time is impressive and the professionalism is second to none.”
Let’s look at what you have, and what you need.
A short conversation is usually all it takes. We’ll review your current coverage, shop our carriers, and walk you through the options in plain language.